So Who Does Windsor, Ontario Think They Are?

Several months back, when Phog Lounge from Windsor, Ontario won Best Live Music Venue in Canada, the collective What the Fuck?!? was heard loud and clear. For most of the country, Windsor, Ontario was the "armpit of Canada", a Southern tip of uselessness known more for its collapsing auto industry and...well, it's collapsing auto industry.
The idea that a small city in an overly Americanized province could lay claim that it had the best live music venue upset many big cities. Many of the countries more widely acclaimed and recognized venues - such as Toronto's "legendary" Horseshoe Tavern, Vancouver's Commodore Ballroom or Halifax's Gus' Pub - should easily have walked over this tiny 60-capacity hubbub. But it didn't. The larger venues coasted on what it thought was a loyal following (only to find out that the following were lazy and assumed they would win hands down) while the Little Venue That Could rallied it's clientele (even gaining national vouching from The Awkward Stage's Shane Nelken) and won the prestigious bragging rights bestowed upon by the mighty CBC Radio 3.
With the recent announcement last week by CBC Radio 3's Grant Lawrence that Phog Lounge would be housing a celebratory concert on July 11 headlined by Holy Fuck, I'm sure there are still a multitude of What The Fucks?!? going on and an amplitude of head scratchings. Just who does Windsor, Ontario think they are?
Well, here's a recap of what Windsor has...musically.
Back in the late 1940's, Windsor entered the musical race with a young jazz singer named Dorothy Collins. This charming young powerhouse of a singer wowed her way to the big time (which means the U.S.) and was soon showcasing her vocal prowess on CBS' radio show, Your Hit Parade. It soon moved over to NBC and Collins soon became a star, appearing on such programs as Candid Camera and The Steve Allen Show. In 1955, she scored her biggest national hit, with the sweet little number "My Boy Flat-Top", which peaked at #16 on the Billboard Charts.
Following up on Collins' success, Windsor's Jack Scott, a greaser rock-and-roller in the same vein as Elvis Presley and Gene Vincent, emerged from an early start (which featured many collaborations with the successful Windsor doo-wop band, The Chantones) to become one of rock and roll radio's early stars. With such monster hits as "The Way I Walk" (which was covered by The Cramps), "My True Love", "What In The World's Come Over You" and more, Scott became an over night sensation. Dave Marsh, one of rock's most respected journalists and a co-editor for Rolling Stone once declared that Jack Scott "undeniably the greatest Canadian rock and roll singer of all time." His 19 singles to hit the Billboard Top 100 in the U.S. is better than such legendary figures as John Lennon, Paul Simon, Metallica, and Cheap Trick (to name a few) - what makes that number more impressive is that all 19 of those hit in a period of 41 months. Only one other recording artist in the history of music has done better than. Four guys from Liverpool named The Beatles.
In the 1960's, apart from one Garth Hudson being born in Windsor and going on to become the multi-instrumentlist genius for Canadian rock pioneers The Band, Windsor's biggest contribution (and one that still resonates today) is arguably Alexander "Skip" Spence. Spence moved from Windsor to the U.S. West Coast and, following a stint as guitarist for Quicksilver Messenger Service, became the original drummer for Jefferson Airplane, playing (and co-writing) on their debut record. He left after the first album to form Moby Grape, writing the band's biggest hit, "Omaha". He left them as well to pursue a solo career that resulted in the highly influential release, Oar (1969). The magnitude of this album is uncalculable, but in 1999, in honour of it's 30th Anniversary, a tribute album was released entitled More Oar, that featured many artists who claimed to be directly influenced by Spence's monumental solo album. So who was so moved that they recorded on this album? For starters, Tom Waits, Led Zeppelin's Robert Plant, Beck, Robyn Hitchock, Mudhoney and Jay Farrar (of Uncle Tupelo and Son Volt fame). Unfortunately, shortly after Oar's release, Spence was diagnosed as a schizophrenic and his contributions for the next 30 years were minimal. He was commissioned to record a song for the X-Files film soundtrack, Songs in the Key of X, entitled "Land of the Sun" (which was ultimately never used, but released later as a 7"), before succumbing to lung cancer shortly before More Oar's release.
The 1970's were generally unkind to Windsor music nationally except for a glam rock outfit called Teaze, who, in typical Spinal Tap fashion, failed to make much of a mark in North America (despite opening for Aerosmith, Triumph, Cheap Trick and Meat Loaf) but became huge in Japan. Windsor's one glimmer of hope was that they were the home for two of Canada's earliest and most influential early punk bands, The Spy's and The Dry Heaves. The Spy's were born in the late 70's after a bunch of friends watched as their guitar playing buddy, Dale "Elad" D'Amore jammed on-stage with MC5 guitarist Fred "Sonic" Smith and decided they should build a band around them. Their resulting single "Machine Shop" is still in demand on eBay. The Dry Heaves followed shortly after and their 1981 release, Don't Shoot Yourself, became an underground gem for Canadian punk rawkers. A 1996 Canadian punk rock tribute album, entitled Oh Canaduh!, featured Vancouver's The Evaporators (featuring the enigmatic Nardwuar The Human Serviette) covering The Dry Heaves' classic "I Can't Puke".
And when Detroit cornered the market on the evolution of electronic and techno music, it was Windsor's own Richie Hawtin - aka Plastikman - who lead the charge and created a style that is as often imitated as it is emulated.
The history of Windsor's contributions to rock and roll's underground as well as commercial break-throughs could go on and on. Everyone knows of Windsor's alternative rock contributions with the blues rock of Big Sugar (Gordie Johnson was raised in Windsor and cut his teeth in Windsor with future Big Sugar bandmate Kelly "Mr. Chill" Hoppe in the Windsor Dukes) and the global sensation of The Tea Party. And more recently, Windsor's Neverending White Lights has conquered radio charts nationwide with his first two releases (including the #1 hit song "The Grace" featuring Dallas Green of City and Colour and Alexisonfire).
So what else has Windsor done recently?
Well, unfortunately, many of Windsor's talents relocate, simply because Windsor doesn't have the variety of venues or economy to properly support its artistic communities, especially musically. A list of evacuees over the past few years includes Christine Fellows, Elliott Brood, The Sunparlour Players, Dean Drouillard, The Golden Hands Before God..., Ron Leary, Songs From A Room, The Unsettlers, Woods of Ypres, Richard White of The Besnard Lakes, Ryan Yoker of Bombs and far too many more to be mentioned.
Luckily, Windsor has plenty of back up. In recent days, the indie pop stylings of Michou has swept the Eastern side of Canada, while others such as Yellow Wood, Pat Robitaille, Tara Watts, MicLordz & Sauce Funky, Explode When They Bloom, The Locusts Have No King, Orphan Choir, Perilelle and others have begun to turn heads. Field Assembly - the brain child of Adam Fox, formerly of Ten Year Drought (who has toured much of this land and our Southern neighbours) - is getting ready to release his debut album (followed soon after by a new Yellow Wood release). The heavier side has never been stronger with Fiftywatthead (on Montreal's Signed By Force label for their latest critically acclaimed Fogcutter), Lodown, Days Fade or Bloodshoteye (who has been endorsed by members of Lamb of God). The future is bright for Windsor area musicians, from metal to indie rock, and its been steamrolling for some time now.
With the economy in Windsor in a constant state of disarray and misery, it provides the perfect gray backdrop to concentrate on music. Now I've lived across this country of ours, from Victoria, BC to Halifax, Nova Scotia, and I can honestly say that the diversity - and the strength by which the scene itself supports such diversity - is unmatched in Windsor. People who support hardcore are just as likely to be at a folk show and vice versa. The honesty in Windsor's music is its strength - pleas of love and cries of anguish, all searching for a better place, a better state of mind, a better wind to blow through Windsor and make it whole again. And those that stay to champion its mean streets will tell you the same thing. You may not think much of this small, blue collar city, but when we decide to tell you a story, chances are, people listen.
Share on Facebook
Stay in Touch:
Subscribe to North by East West by Email






























17 Comments:
Having spent my university years there in the first half of the 90's, I know just what you are talking about. It was a city that always in the shadows of The State Theatre, St Andrew's Hall and The Shelter, but always kind of quietly kept goin' on.
Back then The Coach & Horses, Changez, and The Loop were some fantastic places to be part of the scene. Back when the Phog was the Eclectic.
Truly a great city.
Jammie is right I have lived in Windsor 60 some years and the music here has always been awsome. What he did not mention was CKLW which aired the up and coming MOTOWN sounds of Detroit along side thr rythem and blue of the BRITISH invasion...The only radio station the americans had to equal its power was in Nashvile
He also did not mention the nightclubs in Windsor past, The Elmwoo, Metropole,Killarny Castle, and of course Top Hat..Here you would hear and see live, Ray Charles, Bette Middler, Brenda Lee,
Sonny and Cher, Tom Jones and a thousand other huge acts in music and comedy, it took Las Vagas to kill it. There was a variety of smaller venues as well The Commadore Alex Zonic played his way through University there and at Stanley's Tavern, Lees Imperial House, Spotted Dog,Fanny's the list just goes on.
ron marston
What a great article. This should be posted on the front door of every live music venue in this city and taught in our local high schools. Well done, Jamie.
Scott Warren
Really great, JG. LET'S NOT FORGET ERIC WELTON!!!
Windsor is always one of our favourite places to play.
What about Stacey Heydon? and Rocketface?
Jamie, fantastic article.
You summed up how Windsor has always had a vibrant music scene but that it is always overlooked.
Having all the videos up really made me realize how many great musical acts came and come from Windsor.
Great article, Jamie!
Stacey Heydon could have been mentioned (for those who don't know, his big claim to fame is arguably that he was the man who replaced Earl Slick as David Bowie's lead guitarist in 1976, during the "Station to Station" tour. He went on to become a top producer, most notably producing Sheriff's #1 hit, "When I'm With You") but there are so many stories that could have been mentioned (Ron already pointed out some of them). And yes, Rocketface is another Windsor export, but there are probably hundreds that could have been mentioned as well. I meant no disrespect (I'm assuming by your name tag you're in Rocketface), but I had to keep the article a readable length.
Great Post Jamie - and a good demonstration of why this site needs to be. Toronto, Montreal, Vancouver and Halifax are all great but in Radio 3's two contests to date: best venue and best record store the winners have been Windsor and Prince George B.C. - the reality is that none of Canadas musical communities (including Toronto, Vancouver, Halifax and Montreal) are done justice by the national media. Radio 3 does their best, with limited resources and there are local blogs that cover their local communities well but that's about it. The proper national media is too obsessed with what's going on elsewhere to really bother (most of the time I don't even think they are paying attention.)
Fantastic post! I didn't know any of this, except for the Tea Party. I'm going to link this article to my blog.
Great reading , very inaresting . Always remember playing the Capitol theatre , amomg other venues , with The Super Friendz .
I went to school in windsor last year and actually had a really hard time finding all that you just described, yet everyone that is from the area seems to rave about the scene. Phog, the Loop and Milk were places that I went to often, but I just couldn't seem to find anything resembling a scene or community and was really hoping to be able to. I feel like it is there, but it is not promoted well enough for new people to find it.
However, great article and it's good to know the city has such a rich musical history. It's really a shame I couldn't find it when I was there.
Wonderful article Jamie! Very interesting. Thanks for the read.
Well done. Well written. Go Jamie!
I hope everyone, even remotely involved in the Windsor music scene has a chance to read this piece that Jamie Greer has written.
I was born and raised in Windsor. I lived in Philadelphia for 5 years. I have been back in Windsor for almost 2 years now.
Even living in a big city like Philadelphia, I never faltered in my belief, or the enthusiasm I had sharing it in regards to "this little city in Canada, right next to Detroit" having the best local music ever, hands down.
Even describing it would make me even more impressed, as well as proud, than I already was. Just hearing it all out loud as I would explain to people in Philadelphia and realizing this was so amazing to have. We, as Windsorites, I don't think truly grasp how unique it is and how lucky we are to be able to:
Walk into the MIlk on a Monday and see the age range of talent of The Milkmen, and hear renditions of Radiohead that even the band themselves would be impressed with, I am sure.
Or stroll into the Fishmarket on any Thursday and watch Hooladog do their thing as they do so well with walk ons of trumpet, sax, whamola, and whatever else they can pull out their sleeves.
Step down into the Avalon and Check out Theory of Everything and be blown away that this band is just playing in this little city and no one else will ever know the talent you have the privilege to witness.
Even The Bridge on Wednesday's with Kenneth MacLeod was always a favourite night of mine.
As now is Tuesday nights with his little by means of age but definately not voice, brother Andrew MacLeod on Tuesday nights at the Dominion House or maybe, if you're really lucky, the family will be jamming together. I have to say, the nights I have been there to catch that, has been some of the best live music I have ever gotten the chance to see.
Or even, as Jamie said, heading downstairs to the Coach and watching Fiftywatthead and instantly becoming a faithful follower of this crazy loud, crazy awesome band.
I have loved all the venues, bands and sounds for years that this city has to offer, and after years living in a major city in the USA, still believe they got nothin' on Windsor.
I believe the heart and loyalty radiating out of this little city's venues, artists, and listeners has everything to do with it.
Thanks for the kind words everyone. It is really appreciated.
Oh, ash28...
The Avalon (unfortunately) has been closed now for nearly 2 years and Theory of Everything disbanded longer...but everything else is still totally doable!
I realized after the fact I was typing as if I were telling people about what there was to offer in windsor but not pointing out that it was at the time.
I realize TOE is no longer as well as the Avalon.
Just great memories is all.....
Great indeed.
Post a Comment
Links to this post:
Create a Link
<< Home